Search This Blog

Wednesday, 13 September 2023

Why was the 1916 Rising a (military) failure?

Readings:

What if the guns had landed? | Century Ireland (rte.ie)

Weapons of the 1916 Rising | Century Ireland (rte.ie)

Remembering the 1916 Easter Rising - Day 1: Irish rebels rise | The Irish Post

Remembering the 1916 Easter Rising - Day 2 and 3: The British counterattack | The Irish Post

Remembering the 1916 Easter Rising - Day 4, 5 and 6: Rebel hopes dwindle | The Irish Post

Maynooth men:

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0BxBQjDTFgId4S1JXVXlKRnNzNjA/edit?resourcekey=0-wTXDWMKdxTJyG34w48_XyQ

Essay Plan 

Intro:

P1. Lack of popular support. Most supported Home Rule. Detail HR popularity. IRB small secret organisation.

P2. Lack of armaments. Casement, mission to Germany, failure to secure troops or Irish Division.

P3. Lack of soldiers. Details of volunteers split, MacNeill against rising. Forged castle document and cancelation order. numbers involved. confusion and poor communication.

P4. Goes ahead on the Monday. objective: National uprising or Blood Sacrifice. Seized buildings, read out proclamation,  people thought it was a play.

P5. failed tactics. seizing buildings can only have one outcome. failure to do reconnaissance, failure to take Dublin castle, the telephone exchange, to take railways or ports. Digging trenches in St Stephen's Green.

P6. British response. where troops came from, numbers. 20,000. outnumbered 10-1. confined to Dublin, few elsewhere, Ashbourne, Co. Meath, Wexford.

P7.  Outgunned. Numbers and nature of weapons. Shelling. 4 artillary guns from Athlone and gun boat Helga.

P8. Surrender. detail the final day, civilian casualties. reason for surrender. Unconditional. reaction of the people and why.

P9. A victory of sorts. actions of the British, executions and internment. Dillion. Turned into Martyrs. Blood Sacrifice prophetic.

Conclusion.

Monday, 8 May 2023

Nuremberg Rallies

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4oIf341owrA&t=408s 


The Nuremberg Rallies

 

Intro: Mass Rallies were an integral part of Nazi organization and propaganda. The most important was the annual party rally in Nuremberg each August or September. Early Rallies were held in Munich (1923) and Weimar (1926). The 1927 rally was held in Nuremberg and after the Nazis took power in 1933 Hitler made Nuremberg the permanent location of the party rallies. He choice the medieval city of Nuremberg because of its links with German History – it was regarded as the unofficial capital of the Holy Roman Empire and some imperial Diets were held there. Hitler said it was “the most German of German cities”. There were also practical reasons, it was centrally located with significant accommodation and it had seven railway lines converging there. Nuremberg was also a strong Nazi base – Julius Streicher, who controlled the local organization, he made Nuremberg the “holy city” of the Nazi movement. The rallies served the purpose of making party members feel valued, enticing new followers to the cause due to the special and organization of the event, to glorify Hitler and promote his cult of personality, celebrate Nazi achievements, and launching new party policies and campaigns.

P1: expansion and architecture

Following the Nazis coming to power in 1933 Hitler declared Nuremberg the “city of the Nazi Party rallies” and all the resources of the state were used to expand the annual Nazi celebration. At the 1933 Rally, Albert Speer, a young architect, became involved in the organization of the rally. He constructed a huge wooden framed eagle behind the podium. In 1934 Hitler asked him to draw up an overall plan for the Nazi grounds, which were 11 km in extent. The area had large open spaces such as the Zeppelin Field (could accommodate 100,000 spectators), the Luitpold Arena (could accommodate 150,000 spectators) and the March Field. The plans also included large buildings such as the congress hall (based on ancient roman architecture). These were linked by the Great Road, 2 km long and 60 metres wide. Construction on the site wasn’t finished before war broke out in 1939. Hitler and Speer wanted to create buildings that would last 1000 years. They wanted to match the great buildings of past civilizations such as those of Ancient Greece and Rome. Hitler believed in Speer’s theory of ‘ruin value’ = that ancient ruins provide proof of the greatness of previous civilizations. Speer = “Our architectural works should also speak to the conscience of a future Germany centuries from now”.

P2: themes of the rallies

Each Rally had a different theme, usually celebrating Nazi achievements or launching Nazi policies. 1933 Rally of Victory. Lenifenstahl filmed Victory of Faith at the rally. Ernest Rohm featured in it so most copies destroyed.

1934 the Nazis emphasised the oneness of Germany in the Rally of Unity and Strength. Triumph of the Will was filmed.

1935 Rally of Freedom celebrated breaking the Treaty of Versailles with the introduction of conscription

1936 celebrated the remilitarisation of the Rhineland in the Rally of Honour

1937 Rally of Labour celebrated reduction in unemployment

1938 Rally of Greater Germany celebrated Anschluss. Hitler insisted on the return of the Imperial Regalia of the old Holy Roman Empire from Vienna to Nuremberg. Hitler also used the occasion to put pressure on Czechoslovakia, Britain and France over the Sudetenland.

1939 Rally of Peace cancelled.

Rally used to push Nazi agenda, criticise the Weimar republic or blame Jews and Bolsheviks for Germany’s problems. Campaigns: At the 1935 Rally the Nuremberg laws against the Jews were passed at a special meeting of the Reichstag that was held there.  1936 launched the 4 year plan for economic self-sufficiency and an anti-Bolshevik crusade.

 

P 3: Propaganda

The rally’s were a propaganda event designed to win over the crowds with their grandeur and spectacle. As well as the size of the of the venues, some rallys had over 500,000 attendees, there were spectacles such as the cathedral of light with 130 giant searchlights pointed to the sky around the Zeppelin Field at night or the consecration of the flags ceremony in which Hitler used the Blood flag (the flag sanctified by the blood of those who lost thir lives in the Munich Punsch in 1923) or banner as a symbol of sacrifice and loyalty to the party and touched the new flags with it. 3 biggest flags of all time.  Each part of the Nazi organisation presented themselves before Hitler over the 6 or 7 days of the rally - Hitler Youth, the German Women’s League, the Reich Labour Front, the SA and the SS and the Wehrmacht (armed forces). The  Rallies served to promote Hitler’s cult of personality. At the beginning of  Triumph of the Will Hitler descends in a plane from the clouds like a modern day saviour of his people. Hitler features prominently in the film and at its conclusion he is praised by Hess who says: “the party is Hitler! Hitler is Germany - just as Germany is Hitler! Sieg Heil!  Sieg Heil! Sieg Heil!” To resounding cheers. On each day Hitler’s speech was the highlight of the occasion. “Every word dropped by Hitler seemed like an inspired word from on high. Man’s = or at least the German’s - critical faculty is swept away at such moments, and every lie pronounced is accepted as high truth itself” American journalist William Shirer.

 

P4: Riefenstahl and triumph of the will

In 1934 Hitler commissioned Leni Riefenstahl to film the Nuremberg Rally. Preparations for the rally were linked with preparations for the filming. Nuremberg became a giant stage with flags, banners, marches and torches. Riefenstahl used 30 cameramen and over 100 technicians. She also used planes, cranes, roller skates and tracking rails to shoot the documentary. In all 61 hours of footage was reduced to a 2 hour documentary called “Triumph of the Will”. At the premiere she was greeted coolly by party officials but even Goebbels, her greatest critic, realised it was an outstanding achievement and, in its way, far more effective propaganda for the Fuhrer and National Socialism than any other film yet made” (J Toland). Often regarded as a masterpiece of film propaganda, it was banned for over 50 years. Won awards. Brought the rallies to those who couldn’t attend.

 

conclusion

Recap the NB purposes and effects of the rallies.

Nuremberg had become a key symbol of the Nazis. This, along with its role as a centre of war production, led to massive Allied bombing which flattened much of the city. After the war the US army held a victory parade there and blew up the swastika which was behind the reviewing stand. The trials of the Nazi war criminals were deliberately held in the city.

Thursday, 4 May 2023

Anglo-Irish Relations 1923-49

Read:

 https://www.dropbox.com/s/io9o5aqvfftkkhl/Anglo-Irish-Relations1923-32.ppt?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/rcq45yamhs96nlv/Anglo-Irishrelations1922-1949.doc?dl=0

https://www.625points.com/2019/01/cosgrave-de-valera-anglo-irish-relations-leaving-cert-history.html

https://studyclixsaielive.azureedge.net/cms/media/questionResources/a232829f-c7f4-464f-8978-083511c9b828.pdf

https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=bW91bnR0ZW1wbGUuaWV8bW91bnQtdGVtcGxlLWxlYXZpbmctY2VydGlmaWNhdGUtaGlzdG9yeXxneDoyOTA5MGFjNmFlNjYxM2Qw

https://www.thinkswap.com/ie/leaving-cert/history/higher-level/anglo-irish-relations-under-de-valera

* http://www.gillbooks.ie/AcuCustom/Sitename/DAM/078/MI3_SE_02.pdf


Irish Governments Economic policies 1923-45

https://www.dropbox.com/s/gz4pq9n0tnb3uri/how-successful-were-cumann-na-ngaedheals-economic-policies.doc?dl=0 

https://www.dropbox.com/s/85inqwdjpv35jz8/CumannnanGaedhael1922-1932.doc?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/eglhaq02k54ltzo/CumannnanGaedheal.doc?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/8ku7yrwaujzdvr2/Economicpolicies.doc?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/kwohq8ydgxu9zvr/TheeconomicpoliciesofIrishgovernment.doc?dl=0

Essay plan:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/z45fexmqpa725zw/How%20did%20Irish%20governments%20cope%20with%20the%20economic.docx?dl=0


Friday, 28 April 2023

Topic 3 The pursuit of sovereignty and the impact of partition, 1912-1949

 Ireland: Topic 3 The pursuit of sovereignty and the impact of partition, 1912-1949

 Answer one of the following questions:

 2022

1.   During the period 1912‐1920, what factors contributed to the partition of Ireland?   (100) 

2. How did the Unionist party in power respond to the challenges it faced, 1920‐1945?  (100) 

3. What was the impact of the Eucharistic Congress, 1932, on Irish life? 

4. During the period 1923‐1945, why did Irish governments find it difficult to achieve     economic success? 

 

2021

1. During the period 1912-1921, what attempts were made to obtain self-government for Ireland, and to what extent were they successful? (100)

 

2. During the period 1923-1945, how effectively did Irish governments tackle the social and economic problems they faced? (100)

 

3. What were the successes and failures of Éamon de Valera as a political leader? (100)

 

4. What attempts were made to promote cultural identity in Ireland, North and South? Refer to one or more of the following: language; religion; education.

 

2019

 

1. What was the military and political significance of one or more of the following:  

 

the 1916 Rising; the War of Independence; the Civil War?                   (100)

 

2. What were the main events of the Eucharistic Congress, 1932, and what was its  significance for church and state?     (100)

 

3. What was the impact on Northern Ireland of the world economic crisis of the inter‐war period and/or World War II?              (100)

 

4. How did Anglo‐Irish relations develop during the period 1923‐1949?

 

2018

 

1. How did the Sinn Féin movement develop during the period 1912‐1923?               (100)

 

2. Why were both the negotiations and the terms of the Anglo‐Irish Treaty, 1921,controversial?     (100)

 

3. During the period 1922‐1945, how effective were the governments of both Cosgrave and de Valera in dealing with threats to the security of the state?    (100)

 

4. During the period 1922‐1949, how successful were attempts to make independent Ireland a Gaelic and Catholic society?

 

2017

 

1. During the period 1912‐1920, which factors contributed most to the partition of Ireland? (100)

 

2. During the period 1922‐1939, who achieved more in Anglo‐Irish relations, Cosgrave or de Valera?Argue your case,referring to both.         (100)

 

3. During the period 1922‐1949, how did the 1932 Eucharistic Congress and/or the state’s language and education policies contribute to Irish identity? (100)

 

4. What was the impact of World War II on Ireland, North and South?

 

2016

 

1. What were the main events in Dublin during the 1916 Rising, and was Ireland, in Yeats’phrase, ‘changed utterly’ as a result? (100)

 

2. Why did the conduct and outcome of the Treaty negotiations, October-December, 1921, prove contentious? (100)

 

3. During the period 1912-1940, what were the strengths and weaknesses of James Craig

 

as a political leader? (100)4. How well did Irish governments cope with the social and economic problems they faced, 1923-1945? (100)

 

2013

 

1. What were the fortunes of the Sinn Féin movement during the period 1912-1922? (100)

 

2. During the period 1922-1939, how successful were Irish governments in responding to the economic challenges they faced? (100)

 

3. How did Anglo-Irish relations develop under Éamon de Valera, 1932-1945? 4. What was the impact of World War II on Ireland, North and South? (100)

 

2012

 

1. How did the threat and use of physical force affect Ireland during the period 1912-1923? (100)

 

2. How did the government of Northern Ireland deal with economic problems and/or threats to security, 1920-1945? (100)

 

3. What was the significance of the Eucharistic Congress, 1932? (100)

 

4. How did Anglo-Irish relations develop during the period 1923-1949? (100)

 

2011

 

1. What did one or more of the following contribute to Irish affairs: Patrick Pearse; Arthur Griffith; Countess Markievicz?

 

2. How did the Irish government contribute to the consolidation of democracy, 1922-1932?

 

3. What were the strengths and weaknesses of Éamon de Valera as a political leader? (100)

 

4. What was the impact on Northern Ireland of international developments during the period 1932-1945?

 

2010

 

1. During the period 1912-1920, what factors contributed to the partition of Ireland?

 

2. Who handled Anglo-Irish relations better, W. T. Cosgrave or Éamon de Valera? Argue your case, referring to both.

 

3. To what extent did the 1932 Eucharistic Congress and/or the language and education policies of Irish governments promote Irish cultural identity?

 

4. How did the Unionist Party in power respond to the challenges posed by the existence of a substantial nationalist minority within Northern Ireland?

 

2009

 

1. Why were the Anglo-Irish Treaty negotiations controversial?

 

2. What were the main social and economic challenges facing Northern Ireland, 1920-1945?

 

3. During the period 1932-1945, which did Éamon de Valera manage better, the economy or Anglo-Irish relations? Argue your case, referring to both.

 

4. What attempts were made to promote cultural identity, North and South, during the period, 1912-1945?

 

2008

 

1. To what extent was the Anglo-Irish Treaty, 1921, responsible for the Irish Civil War?

 

2. What steps did Irish governments take to consolidate democracy, 1923-1945?

 

3. What was the significance of the Eucharistic Congress, 1932, for the Irish Free State?

 

4. How well did the Unionist Party manage the affairs of Northern Ireland, 1920-1939?

 

2007

 

1. What were the aims and achievements of Patrick Pearse?

 

2. How did Anglo-Irish relations develop during the period 1923 – 1949?

 

3. How was cultural identity promoted in Ireland, North and South, between 1920 and 1949?

 

4. Following the experience of war, to what extent was the Belfast of 1945 different from that of 1939?

 

2006

 

1. From 1912 onwards, what factors contributed to the partition of Ireland, 1920?

 

2. Between 1922 and 1932, what steps did the Cosgrave governments take to establish the Irish Free State on firm foundations?

 

3. How well did Ireland, North and/or South, deal with the social and economic problems presented by World War II?

 

To what extent were language, religion and education used to promote Irish cultural identity during the period, 19

Friday, 24 March 2023

efforts to promote cultural identity (language, religion and education) north and south essay samples and plans

http://www.theirishstory.com/2011/02/23/the-tailteann-games-1924-1936/#.VlMQVHbhCM-

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5FKzyvzNco


plans and notes:

To what extent were language, religion and education used to promote cultural identity 1920-49?

https://www.dropbox.com/s/uxdoea2aeztvkz9/Essay%20plan%20To%20what%20extent%20were%20language.docx?dl=0

Notes on Language, religion and culture

https://www.dropbox.com/s/j7l89kxishll21u/TheFreeState-languagereligionandcult.doc?dl=0


What attempts were made to promote cultural identity, north and south, during the period,1912-1945

https://www.dropbox.com/s/p60jkeaq0t6xp6u/Essay%20plan%20What%20attempts%20were%20made%20to%20promote%20cultural%20identi.docx?dl=0



What was the significance of the Eucharistic Congress?

powerpoints

https://www.dropbox.com/s/kadxfgt45qvgr14/31st-Eucharistic-Congress-19321.ppt?dl=0#

https://www.dropbox.com/s/glx3tsl4hapnthx/Eucharistic%20Congress%20Mitchell.ppt?dl=0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dKR7olqpL80

https://lchis.wordpress.com/course-topics/ireland-1912-1949/case-studies/the-eucharistic-congress-1932/

notes

https://www.dropbox.com/s/jpd5746zcga8fcb/handout-the-eucharistic-congress-1932.doc?dl=0


sample essays/plans

https://www.dropbox.com/s/vrnywnv1i2uuqr3/What%20was%20the%20significance%20of%20the%20Eucharistic%20Congr.doc?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/r3p20t3rvkavg7m/What%20was%20the%20significance%20of%20the%20Eucharistic%20Congress%201932%20Sample%20answer.docx?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/zfnkx42fy2ry26e/What-was-the-significance-of-the-Eucharistic-Congress-of-1932-to-the-Irish-Free-State.doc?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/yqu9ghoo0yla8p9/what-was-the-significance-of-the-eucharistic-congress.doc?dl=0